Skip to main content

Did the White House Help Roundup's Maker Beat the Cancer Lawsuits?

November 16th, 2026

A Former RFK Jr. Aide Says Yes

The Supreme Court has ruled that states can't require a cancer warning on Roundup that the EPA never approved. Now a former top aide to Health Secretary RFK Jr. says Susie Wiles, the former White House chief of staff, undermined the MAHA agenda and steered the administration toward backing Monsanto. The White House says his claims are false.

The Ruling

On June 25, 2026, the Court ruled 7-2 in Monsanto v. Durnell. Justice Kavanaugh wrote it, and only Justices Jackson and Gorsuch dissented (1). The majority held that federal pesticide law blocks state claims demanding a label different from the EPA-approved one (2). The plaintiff, John Durnell, used Roundup for about 20 years and developed non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. A Missouri jury awarded him more than $1 million, and the Supreme Court overturned it (1). The decision could end more than 100,000 similar lawsuits (3). Monsanto's parent, Bayer, denies that glyphosate causes cancer, and says the litigation has cost it more than $10 billion (4). Justice Jackson's dissent said the majority misreads what the federal law requires (5).

The Twist

RFK Jr. beat Monsanto before. Kennedy helped win a $289 million judgment against Monsanto in 2018 as a lawyer (6). Yet the Justice Department urged the Court to take the case in December 2025 and then argued Bayer's side (7). MAHA leaders called the outcome a betrayal (8).

The Accusation

Calley Means, a senior adviser in Kennedy's HHS office until he resigned October 22, went on the Joe Rogan Experience (#2578, released November 6) and blamed Wiles (7). Watch a clip: The Glyphosate Executive Order That Was 'Not Up for Discussion' (9). The full episode is linked at the bottom. According to that reporting, Means said: Wiles had a "strangle hold" on policy and blocked health reforms to protect donors and industry clients. Her aide Heidi Overton worked with the Justice Department on the pro-Monsanto brief without consulting Kennedy.

A February 2026 glyphosate order was delivered by a Wiles deputy as "not up for discussion."

The Pushback

A White House official told Politico that Overton "was not involved in drafting the brief," and adviser James Blair called Means's claims "made up stuff." Wiles hasn't responded publicly (7). Blair also said he'd consider suing Means if he defamed him (10). Means's accounts of private conversations are unverified, though the court filings do confirm the Justice Department backed Monsanto. On November 6, Trump announced Wiles would move to the Trump Political Operation, and Stephen Miller took over as chief of staff on November 9. The reporting doesn't show the interview caused the move (7). Wiles is out of the chief of staff job now, so time will tell whether the administration's approach to MAHA priorities changes. For now, she has been accused of undermining the MAHA agenda, and those accusations are unproven and denied (7).

What this means for us

At Earthley, we believe you deserve to know what's in the things your family eats, touches and lives around. Bayer and Monsanto's lawyers say regulators have studied glyphosate for decades and found no risk, and that one national label protects farmers (4), (11). Plaintiffs and many in the MAHA movement disagree.

What's settled is the legal point: where the EPA has approved a label, a state jury can't demand a warning. So we'll keep doing what we've always done. We'll read the labels, ask the questions, and choose simple ingredients we trust. And we'll keep watching how this plays out, because we think families are best served when they get the full story.

Sources

Polsinelli: Supreme Court rules FIFRA preempts claims https://www.polsinelli.com/products-liability-toxic-mass-tort/publications/supreme-court-rules-fifra-preempts-state-tort-law-claims-against-monsanto-roundup

Frantz Ward: holding on EPA-approved labeling https://www.frantzward.com/u-s-supreme-court-holds-fifra-preempts-state-failure-to-warn-claims-challenging-epa-approved-labeling/

Yahoo Finance: Supreme Court hears Bayer Roundup case https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/healthcare/articles/supreme-court-hears-bayer-roundup-141009769.html?guccounter=1

Chemical Processing: Court weighs Bayer's fight https://www.chemicalprocessing.com/industrynews/news/55374047/supreme-court-weighs-bayers-fight-against-roundup-lawsuits

NPR: Supreme Court backs Monsanto https://www.npr.org/2026/06/25/g-s1-120233/supreme-court-monsanto-roundup-decision

KVIA: RFK Jr. and the 2018 Monsanto judgment https://kvia.com/politics/cnn-us-politics/2026/04/27/a-supreme-court-case-over-pesticides-is-bringing-out-the-maha-moms-and-threats-of-consequences-for-the-midterms/

Nontoxic Lab: Calley Means on Joe Rogan https://nontoxiclab.com/joe-rogan-glyphosate-white-house-calley-means/

Daily Beast: MAHA turns on Trump after ruling https://www.thedailybeast.com/maha-turn-against-trump-after-stunning-scotus-betrayal-on-glyphosate

KTVZ/CNN: Joe Rogan's show exposes divisions inside the White House Insurance Journal: Supreme Court appears divided

Watch the full interview Joe Rogan Experience #2578 - Calley Means (YouTube, PowerfulJRE channel) https://www.insurancejournal.com/news/national/2026/04/27/867442.htm


Stay Connected

Get updates and exclusive offers straight to your inbox.